is pre-emergent bad for the environment

Is Pre-emergent Bad for the Environment?

Last Updated on August 11, 2023 by Krystine

Pre-emergent herbicides like Preen keep gardens weed-free.

But some question their environmental impact.

With biodiversity declining, it’s crucial to scrutinize whether home and garden care products inadvertently hinder ecological health.

Is Pre-Emergent Bad for the Environment?

Pouring Preen all over their garden patch
For most gardeners, pulling weeds is a fact of life, but by applying the best pre-emergent herbicide, time spent weeding can be significantly reduced. Image Credit: Bob Vila

Pre-emergent herbicides have the potential to harm ecosystems if used irresponsibly.

Chemical ingredients like trifluralin can be toxic to fish and aquatic life when allowed to enter waterways through runoff. Residues also persist in soil over seasons.

However, when applied carefully according to directions and contained from draining, pre-emergents present limited risks for most established mammals, birds, and plants.

Overall, judicious use minimizes environmental impacts, but non-chemical options like corn gluten remain ideal.

Key Points

  • Active pre-emergent ingredients can be toxic to fish and aquatic organisms if drainage occurs.
  • Chemical residues linger in garden soils for extended periods after application.
  • Natural alternatives like corn gluten avoid toxins and residue buildup from synthetic pre-emergents.
  • Careful, limited application as directed reduces environmental release and impact.

How Do Pre-Emergent Herbicides Work?

Pre-emergent herbicides use chemicals to disrupt weed seed germination and establishment, preventing growth.

Active ingredients like trifluralin kill sprouting seeds before they mature and take root.

Some pre-emergents also inhibit plant enzymes and cell processes like cell division and elongation.

This impedes growth, stopping weeds before they start without harming established plants.

What Environmental Effects Do the Active Ingredients Have?

Common active ingredients like trifluralin, pendimethalin, and prodiamine can be toxic to fish and aquatic invertebrates.

Runoff into waterways is problematic.

Some pre-emergents also bind strongly with soil.

This adherence prevents leaching but means chemicals persist longer post-application in gardens versus dissipating quickly.

Established plants absorb little pre-emergent from the soil.

But residue could hypothetically transfer into certain edibles over time in excessive quantities.

Can Pre-Emergents Harm Pets or Wildlife?

Potentially in high concentrations, if pets or wildlife ingest soil recently treated with pre-emergent products.

However, the greatest toxicity risk is to aquatic organisms via pollution runoff.

Using pre-emergents strictly according to label directions minimizes hazards to pets, livestock, and wildlife in treated areas.

While not definitively safe, limited risks exist for mammals and birds at application rates.

Are Natural Alternatives Like Corn Gluten Meal Safer?

A man using corn gluten meal as a pre-emergent herbicide
Corn gluten meal is the new herbicide for lawns. Image Credit: Garden Myths

Yes, corn gluten meal provides pre-emergent control without synthetic chemicals.

It contains no toxins or residues that build up.

However, corn gluten products may require more frequent applications as they biodegrade quicker.

Weighing tradeoffs, corn gluten suits gardens wanting temporary early-season weed prevention without chemical persistence later on.

For longer-term management, some prefer synthesized options despite modest risks.

Can Careful Use Make Pre-Emergents More Eco-Friendly?

Absolutely. Using pre-emergents sparingly on just vulnerable areas reduces environmental release.

Preventing concentrated runoff protects waterways and local biodiversity.

Testing soil annually helps indicate only necessary applications, avoiding excess.

Proper disposal of any leftover product prevents contamination too.

With judicious practices, pre-emergents can be applied with minimal ecological impact.

But avoiding synthetic chemicals entirely remains ideal for sustainability.

How toxic is pre-emergent?

Most pre-emergent products containing ingredients like trifluralin, pendimethalin, or prodiamine range from slightly to highly toxic for fish and aquatic organisms.

Birds and mammals are minimally affected at application concentrations.

When contained, the limited toxicity to established plants and soil organisms enables weed prevention without severe ecological harm.

However, release into bodies of water raises toxicity risks to that ecosystem.

What is an alternative to pre-emergent?

Some good alternatives to synthetic pre-emergent herbicides include corn gluten meal, white vinegar, and non-toxic horticulture corn oil.

These provide early-season weed prevention without lingering chemical residues or aquatic toxicity risks.

Corn gluten meal inhibits root development stopping germination and is also a nitrogen fertilizer.

However, it works best on grassy versus broadleaf weeds. Overall, these options allow weed prevention without chemicals.

Is Preen harmful to wildlife?

When used as directed, Preen weed preventers containing trifluralin have low toxicity risks for most established mammals and birds.

However, trifluralin is highly toxic to fish and aquatic invertebrates.

Runoff into ponds or drains can poison sensitive amphibians also.

The residue persists for months, requiring caution.

While Preen itself has low toxicity when contained, improper usage allowing ecosystem release could potentially harm vulnerable wildlife.

Key Takeaways:

  • Pre-emergent risks require balancing weed management benefits against unknowns of chemical persistence in local ecosystems.
  • Whether the tradeoffs are justifiable depends on individual gardening priorities and risk tolerance.


What are herbicides examples?

Common examples of herbicide types include phenoxy herbicides like 2,4-D, glyphosate herbicides like Roundup, dinitroaniline herbicides like trifluralin, and sulfonylurea herbicides like rimsulfuron. Herbicide categories are based on chemical structure and mode of action in inhibiting plant growth. Popular lawn weed killers often contain 2,4-D, mecoprop-p, dicamba, or combinations called trimec. Agricultural herbicides include atrazine, metolachlor, and paraquat. There are also natural herbicides made from vinegar, citrus oil, or corn gluten meal.

What are organic herbicides?

Organic herbicides control weeds without synthetic chemicals. Examples include corn gluten meal which inhibits root formation, vinegar which burns leaf tissue, soap- or salt-based sprays that dehydrate plants, and certain essential oils like clove, peppermint, and citrus which disrupt plant growth processes when applied. Organic herbicides often require more frequent applications but avoid toxins. They decompose quickly without lingering residues in soil or waterways. However, vinegar and soap can potentially irritate the eyes and skin without caution.

How do herbicides affect plants?

Herbicides affect plants through various modes of action. Glyphosate inhibits the shikimic acid pathway, stopping protein synthesis. 2,4-D mimics plant growth hormones, causing abnormal, uncontrolled tissue growth. Trifluralin inhibits root development and cell division. Paraquat creates destructive reactive oxygen molecules inside plant cells. Most herbicides target biochemical pathways or processes specific to plants to achieve selective toxicity against weeds without harming crops, lawns, or larger organisms lacking those pathways. However, nontarget plants can be affected.

The team at GreenChiCafe is passionate about our natural world and preserving our planet for future generations.

Please check out our website for more content on living sustainably.

Scroll to Top